Compliance
Our Cyber Insurance Renewal Came With a Security Questionnaire. What Are They Actually Asking For, and What Happens If We Say No?
The office manager at a 14-person title and settlement agency in Cranberry Township opened the renewal packet from the agency's cyber insurance carrier expecting a new premium and a signature line. What came instead was a security application with more than forty questions on it. Is multi-factor authentication enforced for all remote access to your network? For all email access? For all administrative accounts? Do you use an endpoint detection and response tool on every workstation and server? Are your backups stored offline or in an immutable format, and when did you last test a restore? Do you verify any request to change wire instructions through a phone call to a known number? She knew the answers to about a third of them. She was fairly sure the honest answer to several others was no. And the agency closes real estate transactions in Butler County every week, which means wire instructions are the single most valuable thing in the building.
That is where a lot of small businesses in Western Pennsylvania and eastern Ohio are this year. Cyber insurance requirements have quietly changed from a formality to a checklist of specific technical controls, and the person filling out the form is usually not the person who could answer it. This post walks through what carriers are actually asking for, what each question means in plain English, what happens if the honest answer is no, and how to get to yes before your renewal date instead of after a claim.
Why did our cyber insurance application suddenly get so technical?
Because carriers spent several years paying for small-business ransomware and email fraud, and they learned which missing controls kept showing up in the claims.
A few years ago a small business could buy a cyber policy with a short application and a handful of yes or no questions. That market is gone. Carriers now underwrite the way a building insurer would ask about sprinklers and fire alarms: they want to know which specific protections are in place before they price the risk, and some will not offer coverage at all without certain ones. Some carriers also run their own outside scan of your internet-facing systems before they quote, looking for things like an exposed remote desktop connection or an email domain with no spoofing protection. In other words, part of the answer is already known to them before you fill out the form.
The result is that the renewal packet has become the most detailed security review many small businesses have ever received, and it arrives from someone who is not trying to sell you anything. That makes it worth taking seriously even if your premium did not move.
What are the cyber insurance requirements carriers ask small businesses about?
The wording varies by carrier, but the same core cyber insurance requirements show up on nearly every small-business application. Here they are in plain English, with what the question is really getting at.
- Multi-factor authentication (MFA) on email. A code or app prompt in addition to the password for everyone's mailbox, including the owner's and any shared accounts. This is the single most common requirement, because stolen email passwords are how most fraud starts.
- MFA on remote access. Any way into the network from outside the building (a VPN, a remote desktop tool, a cloud file share) needs a second factor. An exposed remote desktop connection with only a password is close to an automatic decline with many carriers.
- MFA on administrator accounts. The accounts that can change everything (the IT provider's logins, the domain administrator, the Microsoft 365 global admin) need it too. Carriers ask separately because businesses often protect staff accounts and forget these.
- Endpoint detection and response (EDR). Not traditional antivirus, but software that watches for attack behavior on every computer and server and can stop it in progress. The question usually asks whether it is on every device and whether someone monitors its alerts. Our endpoint protection page explains the difference.
- Backups an attacker cannot reach. Carriers ask whether backups are offline, separated from your network, or immutable (they cannot be changed or deleted for a set period), and when you last tested a full restore. A backup drive plugged into the server it protects does not count, because ransomware encrypts it along with everything else. We covered what a real setup looks like in cloud backup for small business.
- Patching on a schedule. How quickly critical security updates are applied, and whether you run any software the manufacturer no longer supports (an old Windows server, an out-of-date accounting system). End-of-life systems are a frequent reason for exclusions.
- Email filtering and spoofing protection. Whether incoming email is screened for malicious links and attachments, and whether your domain has the settings that stop criminals from sending email that appears to come from you. Email security covers both.
- Security awareness training and phishing tests. Whether employees are trained at least annually and tested with simulated phishing emails. Carriers want a date and a record, not a promise.
- A written incident response plan. Who gets called, in what order, when something goes wrong. Many policies require you to contact the carrier's breach hotline first, so the plan needs that number in it.
- Wire and payment verification. Whether any request to change bank or wire details is confirmed by a call to a phone number you already had on file, never the number in the email. This question decides whether the policy's social engineering or funds transfer coverage applies at all.
If you are wondering how the network side of that list (firewall, remote access, monitoring) fits together, our post on network security for small business goes through it in order.
What happens if we answer yes to something we do not actually have?
This is the most important question on this page, and it is the one owners skip.
The application is not a survey. It is part of the policy, and the answers are representations the carrier relies on when it agrees to cover you. If you file a claim, the carrier's investigators will look at how the attacker got in, and they will compare what they find to what you said on the application. If you said MFA was enforced on email and the breach started with a mailbox that had no MFA, the carrier can argue the policy was issued based on a misstatement. Depending on the policy language and the circumstances, that can mean a reduced payout, a denied claim, or the carrier seeking to cancel the policy back to the day it started. Carriers have taken exactly this position in court after small-business ransomware claims.
So the person signing the application is, in effect, attesting to the state of your IT. If that person is the office manager or the owner, and the controls were set up by an outside provider years ago, the honest answer to "is MFA enforced on all remote access" may genuinely be "I do not know." That is a much better answer to find out now than during a claim.
Answering no is not the end of the world. A no usually means a higher premium, a lower limit, an exclusion for that kind of loss, or a requirement to fix it by a date. A false yes can mean no coverage at all when you need it.
How do these requirements play out for a title agency, a medical office, or a retailer?
The core list is the same, but which question matters most depends on what you do.
For the Cranberry title agency, it was the wire question. Title and settlement firms are the textbook target for business email compromise: a criminal gets into an email account (yours, the realtor's, or the buyer's), watches the conversation, and sends new wire instructions right before closing. Many cyber policies cover that loss under a separate social engineering or funds transfer section with its own, often much smaller, limit, and some only pay if you followed a call-back verification procedure. Lenders and title underwriters ask about the same controls through their own vendor reviews, so the work does double duty. We go through the full set of payment controls in our post on how business email compromise works and how to stop it.
For a medical or dental practice, the questions overlap almost completely with HIPAA. A carrier asking about encryption, access controls, and backups is asking about the same things a HIPAA security risk analysis covers, which is why we suggest doing the two together. Our post on the HIPAA security risk assessment explains what that analysis includes.
For a restaurant or retailer that takes cards, the network questions line up with PCI requirements: card terminals separated from guest wifi and office computers, a managed firewall, and remote access locked down.
For accountants, attorneys, and insurance agencies, it is the volume of Social Security numbers and financial records that drives the carrier's concern, and Pennsylvania's breach notification law means a loss of that data carries notification obligations on top of the cleanup.
How do we close the gaps before our renewal date?
Start early. Some of these controls take a weekend; others take a few weeks to roll out without disrupting the office. Ninety days before renewal is comfortable. Thirty days is tight but workable for most small businesses.
A practical order that matches how carriers weigh the questions:
1. Get the application in front of whoever manages your IT, and have them answer each question with evidence, not memory. A screenshot of the MFA policy beats "I think so."
2. Turn on MFA everywhere carriers ask about, starting with email and remote access, then administrator accounts. This closes the most claims for the least effort.
3. Fix the backups. Make sure at least one copy is offline or immutable, then do a test restore and write down the date and result.
4. Replace traditional antivirus with EDR on every computer and server, and confirm someone is actually watching the alerts.
5. Write down the wire verification procedure, train the people who handle payments on it, and use it every time.
6. Schedule training and a phishing test, and keep the completion records. Our post on what a real security awareness program looks like has the details.
7. Write a one-page incident response plan with the carrier's breach hotline at the top.
If you do not know where you stand on half the list, the fastest route is a cybersecurity assessment that checks each control against what the application asks and gives you a prioritized list of what to fix before the renewal date. If you already know the gap is bigger than one renewal (nobody is really monitoring anything after hours), our post on outsourcing cyber security covers how small businesses get that coverage without hiring a security team.
Can our IT provider help fill out the cyber insurance questionnaire?
They should, and if they will not, that tells you something.
A good IT provider should be able to sit with the application, answer the technical questions accurately, show you the evidence behind each yes, and give you a plain list of what is still a no along with what it would take to fix it. They should not answer yes on your behalf to make the form go away. Your insurance agent can explain the coverage side (limits, sublimits, exclusions, the social engineering section), but the technical answers need to come from someone who can see your systems.
The Cranberry title agency answered its renewal honestly with three items marked as in progress and dates attached. By the time the policy bound, MFA was on every mailbox and remote connection, the backups had an offline copy with a tested restore, and every wire change was being confirmed by phone. The office manager now has a folder with the evidence for every answer, and next year's renewal will take an afternoon.
MCR Business Tech Solutions helps small and mid-sized businesses across Butler, Mercer, Lawrence, Crawford, Erie, and Allegheny counties, and in Trumbull and Mahoning counties in Ohio, answer their cyber insurance applications truthfully and close the gaps before the renewal date. If a questionnaire is sitting on your desk, call us at 833-859-9021 or Request an IT assessment and we will go through it with you question by question.